Skip to main content

10/10 scores revisited, ridiculed

The VG247 logo in white on a red background
Image credit: VG247

halo2a.jpg

GameDaily's gone back over its 10/10 reviews, finding some of them distinctly lacking.

Not news as such, but an interesting exercise nonetheless. The Call of Duty 3 write-up's pretty funny.

"Our ridiculous Call of Duty 3 review dares to ask the question, 'Greatest World War II video game?' and then follows it up with the erroneous 'best war game, period.' We'd love to know how that's possible with a game that features lame vehicle segments and an unbalanced multiplayer mode that makes it almost impossible for the Germans to win.

Halo 2 doesn't fare much better.

Much like Call of Duty 3, we still cry over our decision to award Halo 2 a perfect score. The romantic story of a rogue alien and a super soldier with zero personality arguably ruined the franchise, and yet, we felt the need to call it "the mother of all first person shooters" and "a milestone in video game history."

We're looking at you. Worth a nose.

Read this next

Patrick Garratt avatar
Patrick Garratt is a games media legend - and not just by reputation. He was named as such in the UK's 'Games Media Awards', the equivalent of a lifetime achievement award. After garnering experience on countless gaming magazines, he joined Eurogamer and later split from that brand to create VG247, putting the site on the map with fast, 24-hour a day coverage, and assembling the site's earliest editorial teams. He retired from VG247, and the games industry, in 2017.
In this article

Call of Duty 3

PS3, Xbox 360, PS2, Nintendo Wii, Xbox

Halo 2

Xbox

Related topics

Sign in and unlock a world of features

Get access to commenting, homepage personalisation, newsletters, and more!